Spring Garden Towers/PCOM

PCOM surgery amphitheater.png
Surgical Amphitheater 1925, at 1822 Spring Garden Street, from source here.
2018 is the centennial of a hospital building that still stands 300 feet north of Baldwin Park. Many neighbors have been inside without realizing its original purpose. But let's start with a former mayor of Philadelphia who lived in the Baldwin Park neighborhood.
John Edgar Reyburn (1845-1914) was Mayor of Philadelphia from 1907 to 1911 after serving a few terms in the US House of representatives. He lived at 1822 Spring Garden Street, on the southeast corner of 19th and Spring Garden Streets, in a house he had built in 1871. Reyburn was best known, as far as the Baldwin Park neighborhood is concerned, for overseeing the slight redirection of the proposed Ben Franklin Parkway from just north of Fairmount Reservoir to its current course directly toward the former reservoir and now towering Philadelphia Museum of Art. The model below in the mayor's office from 1911 was part of his sales pitch for the Parkway. The spectacular view from the Rocky steps to City Hall was saved by Reyburn, but with a substantial $2 million price tag for that slight shift. 
parkway realignment.jpeg
Parkway model 1911.png
Post-Reyburn plan. Beautiful straight line view from future Rocky footprints to Billy Penn's hat has been preserved
Mayor Reyburn advocated for the funding and completion of the Fairmount Parkway (renamed the Benjamin Franklin Parkway in 1937), and the open space just northwest of City Hall was named Reyburn Plaza in his honor. The section of the model below shows the proposed plaza with a band shell, but the size shown in the model was scaled back. The stage pictured in the 1952 photo was last used in 1960 for a campaign speech by John F. Kennedy, and torn down shortly afterward. The plaza was elevated and rebuilt in 1962, and is the site of the Municipal Building and the giant game pieces. Although dominated by the statue of another mayor by the name of Rizzo (statue dedicated in 1998), and often called Thomas Paine Plaza, it is still officially Reyburn Plaza. 
Reyburn Plaza model 1911.png
Planned band shell in plaza directly in center.
Reyburn plaza 1952.png
The Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine (PCOM) was founded in 1898, 25 years after the origination of osteopathy by frontier physician Andrew Taylor Still. Osteopathy and homeopathy, which was started by Samuel Hahnemann in 1796, were alternatives to the standard practice of medicine. Homeopathy believed that giving potions diluted to almost zero concentrations, these potions causing symptoms similar to the disease symptoms ("homeo" means same), would promote healing. Osteopathy believed that muscle and bone manipulation would cure non-musculoskeletal diseases ("osteo" means bone). Hahnemann coined the term allopathy to describe the conventional medicine of the time, in which medications had effects different than the symptoms of the disease, like an anti-fever drug for fever ("allo" means different).
At the time homeopathy and osteopathy were developed, allopathy was just beginning to establish a scientific basis. Bloodletting, purges with mercury, and cold water treatments were allopathic therapies which often caused more harm than good for the poor patient. Osteopathy and homeopathy essentially did nothing, including nothing harmful, and therefore often gave better results. To be blunt, doing nothing or giving placebo treatments was better than conventional medicine. As the germ theory of disease gained acceptance in the second half of the 19th century (see Preston Retreat article here), allopathy began to reject non-evidence based treatments. Both osteopathy and homeopathy lacked mechanistic plausibility and became regarded as quackery, and now both Hahnemann and Osteopathic Colleges teach standard allopathy.
The first home of PCOM was in the Girard Building at 21 South 12th Street in 1899 (building still there), then moved to an equally impressive Witherspoon Building at Juniper and Walnut in 1900 (also still there). The peripatetic PCOM then moved to 33rd and Arch in 1903; 1715 Broad Street in 1908; 832 Pine Street in 1912; and then had an extended stay at the Reyburn Mansion from 1916-1928. The school expanded into two houses to the east of the Reyburn Mansion, at 1820 and 1818 Spring Garden Street, and then added a hospital behind 1822 Spring Garden on vacant land.
PCOM SG Reyburn Mansion.png
1818-1822 Spring Garden Street PCOM buildings in 1925, as seen from the northeast. The Reyburn Mansion is on the far right. Image from The Athenaeum.
PCOM 1925 yearbook image.png
PCOM buildings as seen from the northwest (image from 1925 PCOM yearbook).
spring garden tower neighbor with eagles
Same view from the northwest today. Note (for later) double eagles on the top of the curved corner on the art deco building. Spring Garden Towers in background.
The neighborhood then was a hotbed of "eds and meds." Preston Retreat and the surrounding women's health care centers were described here, and the Bromley map from 1922 below shows other medical buildings, some of which will be discussed on this website in the future. PCOM took shape by 1922. The Garretson Hospital for Oral Surgery had been built in 1879 on a very long and narrow lot on Buttonwood Street, and a later addition designed by Horace Trumbauer was placed to infill between Buttonwood and Hamilton Streets. This private hospital merged with Temple in 1907 and eventually became a 75-bed general hospital. In 1923 Temple acquired the 30-bed Joseph Price Maternity Hospital, a private hospital at 1808-1812 Spring Garden Street. On the 1942 land use map one can see that 1818 and 1820 have been demolished, leaving the "V" for vacant land.
PCOM map 1922.png
In this detail from the 1922 Bromley map can be seen the Osteopathic Hospital, Garretson Hospital, and the State College of Optometry at 1809 Spring Garden Street. The Baldwin Locomotive Works at bottom occupies the northern half of what is now Baldwin Park.
Garretson 1942 land use map.png
This detail from a 1942 land use map shows Garretson Hospital and the Optometry College still there (the college moved in 1932, but 1809 Spring Garden remained as an eye clinic and extended through the block by acquiring 1810 Brandywine). The Osteopathic Hospital at 1822 Spring Garden Street has been repurposed and the annex buildings at 1820 and 1818 demolished. The private Joseph Price Maternity Hospital became part of the Temple system. 
On the north side of Spring Garden Street at number 1809 was the Pennsylvania State College of Optometry, one of the first in the United States. It was founded in the year 1919 on Spring Garden Street, just two blocks west of Wills Eye Hospital (now the Colonnade Condominiums), and moved to Oak Lane in 1932. In the ad below you can see a modern sounding sales pitch to potential students. The exquisite building  underwent a facade-ectomy to be converted to a less exquisite labor union building. 
optometry college ad.png
Hard sell to potential students: classes almost full; tougher requirements and longer courses coming. Act now!
penn college of optometry building.png
Two views of Optometry College in 1919 
labor union 1809 Spring Garden.jpeg
College site in 2018 
In 1928 PCOM moved to a new building at 48th and Spruce (still there) and was there until 1973, when it moved to its current location on City Line Avenue. 1818 and 1820 Spring Garden Streets were demolished sometime between 1934 and 1942, but the Reyburn Mansion and Osteopathic Hospital buildings are still there. The hospital building has undergone minimal modifications. The corner mansion had the top floor and facade removed, losing the gambrel roof, dormers, bay windows, and detailed facade. The round edge at the corner was maintained with the new entrance placed there on the art deco renovation. The bike shop on 19th Street has the address of 1822 Spring Garden, and that address is one long interconnected building from Spring Garden to Buttonwood, as was the hospital building (although the original structures were only connected via the lowest level floor).
PCOM corner view better.png
PCOM 2018.jpeg
PCOM hospital building on corner of 19th and Buttonwood as seen from the southwest: 1925 on left and today on right.
The Reyburn Mansion/PCOM Hospital survived the bulldozers from the Franklin Town developers, as this 1970 aerial photo shows. Note the round edges of the building at 19th and Spring Garden Streets.
PCOM aerial 1970.png
Detail from 1970 aerial photo survey of Philadelphia
So what happened to those vacant lots at 1818-1820 Spring Garden Street? In 1979 Lutheran Associates completed a single tower called Spring Garden Towers, a 17 story subsidized apartment complex for older folks. There are 208 units, all one bedroom, one bath with an average square footage of 300 square feet. It has minimal windows on its north and south faces, with most windows on the east and west faces. The 16 story Museum Towers I, built in 1987, obstructed many of the views from the east side of Spring Garden Towers. Museum Towers II, built in 2016, blocked more of the easterly views from Spring Garden Towers. The Museum Towers complex, now called NorthxNorthwest, includes 570 apartments in the two towers combined, plus 16 two story townhouses along 19th Street and Baldwin Park, and a 400 car parking lot behind the townhouses.
museum towers rendering.png
The original Reyburn Mansion itself at 1822 Spring Garden was used as it currently is, as a home for small businesses, from 1928 onwards. The hospital building also had a succession of businesses, including a casket maker, a produce market, and a flower shop. In 2004 Nette Properties LLC. bought 1822 Spring Garden for $1.8 million. Unbeknownst to Nette, in 1975 the then owner of 1822 Spring Garden had sold the air rights to Franklin Town, and the land rights were sold to Aron and Melba Cohen. Franklin Town in 1976 sold the air rights to Lutheran Associates. In 1980 the land rights were sold to Claire Nelson. In 1997 Nelson paid off the installation payments and the deed had no mention of air rights being excluded. In 2004 Nelson decided to sell the property. Nelson received a quit claim deed for air rights from Franklin Town in January 2004, which was not helpful when Nette bought the property in June of 2004, since Franklin Town had sold the air rights 28 years earlier. In December 2005 Nette signed an agreement of sale for $3.9 million with a developer, Meyer Greenbaum, who planned to build a 40 story building.  The neighborhood association opposed the height of the proposed structure, but their opposition was to become moot anyway. In August 2006 Lutheran Associates asserted their ownership of the air rights, and Greenbaum walked away from the deal. Result: lawsuits with a multitude of parties and cross-claims. In 2007 claims were settled with Nelson owing Nette the $100,000 difference between its purchase price and the value of the land rights alone. Lesson: if you are buying for the view, buy up neighboring air rights.
1822 SG proposed condo tower 2004.png
Proposed 40 story tower at 1822 Spring Garden Street. Note the adaptive reuse of those two eagles from the art deco precursor, although most people don't notice them two stories up, never mind forty stories. 
1822 Spring Garden air rights 2004.jpeg
Arrow shows site of proposed tower and why those interested in views from Spring garden Towers might object.
Spring Garden Towers today has two other features, one interesting and one annoying, that merit comment. In the southeast corner of the building, best seen along Buttonwood Square (the driveway south of the building), there is a retaining wall that are remnants of a set of steps that went from Buttonwood Street to the back of a Linton's Restaurant at 1816 Spring Garden Street in the 1960's. Linton's was a Philadelphia chain that served "faster" food, but the restaurants fell victims to the really fast food chains of the 1970's. That is the interesting feature.
stone wall spring garden towers 2.jpeg
Stone blocks forming wall behind Spring Garden Towers, 2018. This wall section would have been the western side of a staircase from Buttonwood Street to Linton's Restaurant in the 1960's.
The annoying feature is the Spring Garden Street sidewalk in front of 1822 Spring Garden Street. As one can see in the image of the current sidewalk, the planter in front of 1822 Spring Garden and the tree make a less than three foot passageway on the sidewalk. There was a lawsuit decided in 1875, in which the owner of 1818 Spring Garden Street sought to prevent the owner of 1822 Spring Garden, Mayor John Reyburn, from building a bay window on the front of his house. In 1860, curb to house distance was set at 35 feet, shortened in 1864 to 19 feet to allow owners to put 16 foot wide gardens in front of their houses. Nineteen foot wide footways were to be preserved. Even though Reyburn's 4 foot deep bay window was to be over the garden, not the sidewalk, his neighbor brought him to court. Reyburn won the case and built those beautiful bay windows. I would like to think it is karmic payback that the owners of 1822 built the intruding planter in front of their building to leave neighbors at 1818 with less than a three foot sidewalk! See 3 page court ruling here.
sidewalk spring garden tower to west.jpg
Less than three foot wide footway in front of 1822 Spring garden Street. Reyburn's revenge?
Spring Garden Towers from Baldwin Park.j
Spring Garden Towers, 2018, looking northwest from Baldwin Park
authored by Joe Walsh, November 2018